Citation: | Wang L T,He J,Hou R B. 2025. Model for H/V acceleration response spectral ratio for non-scenario earthquakes from the subduction interface. Acta Seismologica Sinica,47(2):269−283. DOI: 10.11939/jass.20230169 |
Vertical ground motions acceleration response spectrum is an important part of the structural seismic design, and the domestic and foreign seismic design codes use the H/V response spectrum ratio to calculate the vertical ground motion response spectrum indirectly, which is a simple and feasible method, but the current seismic codes are still too rough for the vertical ground motions response spectrum, which will underestimate the role of vertical component in the engineering application or will result in redundancy in the application. In addition, the geological structure of the subduction zone is complex and earthquakes occur frequently, and the interface earthquakes have the characteristics of high magnitude and high intensity, so it is necessary to study the interface earthquakes in the subduction zone separately.
In this paper, based on the surface observation data obtained from the KiK-net and K-NET in Japan, the data are first preprocessed so as to improve the accuracy of the model and to eliminate the seismic records that affect the fitting effect, which involves filtering the magnitude and the fault distance of the data, checking the acceleration time history, then correcting the instrumental response and filtering the waveforms. Finally, 3 048 seismic records from 59 interface earthquakes in subduction zones are selected for the study, and the acceleration response spectra are calculated for each record with 5% damping ratio. Random-effects algorithms and mathematical statistics were used to analyze the effects of spectral period, earthquake type and site conditions on the H/V response spectral ratio. Based on the site period Ts division of site classes, the H/V response spectrum ratio model for non-scenario earthquakes (without source and path parameters) from the subduction interface is established, the model coefficients are smoothed and adjusted to facilitate engineering applications, and the standard deviation of model residuals is evaluated and analyzed to explore the magnitude and source of random residuals and to improve the accuracy and reliability of the model. The model can be used to adjust the response spectrum of engineering seismic design when there is no earthquake source and no path information.
The study shows that: ① t-test method verifies that the type of earthquake and the site classes have a significant effect on the H/V response spectral ratio, so it is necessary to establish the corresponding response spectral ratio models according to different types of earthquakes and site classes; ② The peak period of the site effect term coefficients is close to the average period for each type of site, indicating that the site term coefficients are reasonably well taken to elicit a resonant site response. In the prediction model, the peak period of the H/V response spectral ratio is 0.2 s for classⅠsites, 0.27 s for class Ⅱ sites, and 0.5 s for class Ⅲ sites. The peak period of the H/V response spectral ratio in the prediction model has a certain correlation with the site predominant period, which can prove that the H/V response spectral ratio model is well fitted by using the random-effects method; ③ The standard deviation analysis shows that the dispersion generated by the source effect is smaller than that generated by the path effect and the site effect, the random residuals of the path effect term and the site effect term contribute more to the model variability, indicating that the random residuals of the horizontal and vertical components of the seismic records have strong correlation. Different site classes produce the largest dispersion in response spectral ratios at their corresponding mean site period. The increasing dispersion of the H/V response spectral ratio due to path effects with increasing spectral period demonstrates that the correlation between the horizontal and vertical component random path residuals decreases with increasing period.
The H/V response spectral ratio model for non-scenario earthquakes established in this study has the characteristics of simplicity and convenience for engineering application, and the source and path parameters are not added into the model. Residual analysis shows that the between-event residuals are correlated with the magnitude and fault depth, and the effects of magnitude and fault depth on the between-event residuals are clearly segmented at magnitude 7.1 and fault depth of 25 km. There is a correlation between the within-site residuals and the fault distance. Moreover, the effects of magnitude, source depth and fault distance on the residuals change with the spectral period, the seismic source characteristics and propagation paths still affect the H/V response spectral ratio. Therefore, when there is clear seismic information, the introduction of magnitude, fault distance, fault depth and other factors can further improve the model prediction accuracy, and will be committed to constructing a more accurate H/V response spectral ratio model in the future research. The results of this paper are of reference value for the seismic fortification of offshore engineering.
薄景山,李琪,齐文浩,王玉婷,赵鑫龙,张毅毅. 2021. 场地条件对地震动和震害影响的研究进展与建议[J]. 吉林大学学报(地球科学版),51(5):1295–1305.
|
Bo J S,Li Q,Qi W H,Wang Y T,Zhao X L,Zhang Y Y. 2021. Research progress and discussion of site condition effect on ground motion and earthquake damage[J]. Journal of Jilin University (Earth Science Edition),51(5):1295–1305 (in Chinese).
|
耿淑伟,陶夏新. 2004. 地震动加速度反应谱竖向分量与水平分量的比值[J]. 地震工程与工程振动,24(5):33–38.
|
Geng S W,Tao X X. 2004. The ratios of vertical to horizontal acceleration response spectra[J]. Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration,24(5):33–38 (in Chinese).
|
蒋飞. 2018. 日本俯冲带地区竖向地震动衰减关系研究[D]. 成都:西南交通大学:16−78.
|
Jiang F. 2018. Ground-Motion Prediction Equations for the Vertical Component From Subduction Zone Earthquakes in Japan[D]. Chengdu:Southwest Jiaotong University:16−78 (in Chinese).
|
姜明秀,张潇男,康莉莉. 2019. 俯冲带板内地震水平加速度谱的阻尼比修正系数模型研究[J]. 地震工程与工程振动,39(4):126–138.
|
Jiang M X,Zhang X N,Kang L L. 2019. A study on damping correction factor model for acceleration response spectrum for the horizontal components from subduction slab earthquakes[J]. Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Dynamics,39(4):126–138 (in Chinese).
|
李恒,秦小军. 2010. 竖向与水平向地震动加速度反应谱比特性分析[J]. 地震工程与工程振动,30(1):8–14.
|
Li H,Qin X J. 2010. Study on characteristics of vertical to horizontal acceleration response spectral ratio[J]. Journal of Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration,30(1):8–14 (in Chinese).
|
李小军,陈苏,任治坤,吕悦军,童华炜,温增平. 2020. 海域地震区划关键技术研究项目及研究进展[J]. 地震科学进展,50(1):2–19.
|
Li X J,Chen S,Ren Z K,Lü Y J,Tong H W,Wen Z P. 2020. Project plan and research progress on key technologies of seismic zoning in sea areas[J]. Progress in Earthquake Sciences,50(1):2–19 (in Chinese).
|
石磐. 2017. 俯冲带地区的基岩反应谱及横竖向反应谱比研究[D]. 成都:西南交通大学:21−22.
|
Shi P. 2017. A Study on the Rock Site Spectrum and its H/V Ratio of Earthquake in Subduction Zone[D]. Chengdu:Southwest Jiaotong University:21−22 (in Chinese).
|
谢俊举,温增平,高孟潭,胡聿贤,何少林. 2010. 2008年汶川地震近断层竖向与水平向地震动特征[J]. 地球物理学报,53(8):1796–1805.
|
Xie J J,Wen Z P,Gao M T,Hu Y X,He S L. 2010. Characteristics of near-fault vertical and horizontal ground motion from the 2008 Wenchuan earthquake[J]. Chinese Journal of Geophysics,53(8):1796–1805 (in Chinese).
|
徐龙军,谢礼立. 2007. 竖向地震动加速度反应谱特性[J]. 地震工程与工程振动,27(6):17–23.
|
Xu L J,Xie L L. 2007. Characteristics of acceleration response spectra for vertical ground motions[J]. Journal of Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration,27(6):17–23 (in Chinese).
|
张齐. 2016. 地震动衰减关系的区域性差异研究[D]. 哈尔滨:中国地震局工程力学研究所:93−131.
|
Zhang Q. 2016. Study on Regional Differentiation of Ground Motion Attenuation Relationship[D]. Harbin:Institute of Engineering Mechanics,China Earthquake Administration:93−131 (in Chinese).
|
中国建筑科学研究院. 2010. GB/T 50011—2010 建筑抗震设计标准[S]. 北京:中国建筑工业出版社:25.
|
China Academy of Building Research. 2010. GB/T 50011−2010 Code for Seismic Design of Buildings[S]. Beijing:China Architecture & Building Press:25 (in Chinese).
|
周锡元,徐平,王国权,闫维明. 2006. 1999年台湾集集地震近断层竖向与水平反应谱比值的研究[J]. 地震地质,28(3):325–335.
|
Zhou X Y,Xu P,Wang G Q,Yan W M. 2006. A case study on near fault vertical to horizontal response spectral ratio from the 1999,Chi-Chi,Taiwan,earthquake[J]. Seismology and Geology,28(3):325–335 (in Chinese).
|
周正华,周雍年,卢滔,杨程. 2003. 竖向地震动特征研究[J]. 地震工程与工程振动,23(3):25–29.
|
Zhou Z H,Zhou Y N,Lu T,Yang C. 2003. Study on characteristics of vertical ground motion[J]. Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration,23(3):25–29 (in Chinese).
|
Abrahamson N A,Youngs R R. 1992. A stable algorithm for regression analyses using the random effects model[J]. Bull Seismol Soc Am,82(1):505–510. doi: 10.1785/BSSA0820010505
|
Bozorgnia Y,Niazi M,Campbell K W. 1995. Characteristics of free-field vertical ground motion during the Northridge earthquake[J]. Earthq Spectra,11(4):515–525. doi: 10.1193/1.1585825
|
Bozorgnia Y,Campbell K W. 2004. The vertical-to-horizontal response spectral ratio and tentative procedures for developing simplified V/H and vertical design spectra[J]. J Earthq Eng,8(2):175–207.
|
Cultrera G,Cornou C,Di Giulio G,Bard P Y. 2021. Indicators for site characterization at seismic station:Recommendation from a dedicated survey[J]. Bull Earthq Eng,19(11):4171–4195. doi: 10.1007/s10518-021-01136-7
|
Xie J J,Li K W,Li X J,An Z,Wang P F. 2023. vS30-based relationship for Chinese site classification[J]. Eng Geol,324:107253. doi: 10.1016/j.enggeo.2023.107253
|
Zhao J X,Zhang J,Asano A,Ohno Y,Oouchi T,Takahashi T,Ogawa H,Irikura K,Thio H K,Somerville P G,Fukushima Y,Fukushima Y. 2006a. Attenuation relations of strong ground motion in Japan using site classification based on predominant period[J]. Bull Seismol Soc Am,96(3):898–913. doi: 10.1785/0120050122
|
Zhao J X,Irikura K,Zhang J,Fukushima Y,Somerville P G,Asano A,Ohno Y,Oouchi T,Takahashi T,Ogawa H. 2006b. An empirical site-classification method for strong-motion stations in Japan using H/V response spectral ratio[J]. Bull Seismol Soc Am,96(3):914–925. doi: 10.1785/0120050124
|
Zhao J X,Xu H. 2013. A comparison of vS30 and site period as site-effect parameters in response spectral ground-motion prediction equations[J]. Bull Seismol Soc Am,103(1):1–18. doi: 10.1785/0120110251
|
Zhao J X,Hu J S,Jiang F,Zhou J,Zhang Y B,An X W,Lu M,Rhoades D A. 2015a. Nonlinear site models derived from 1D analyses for ground-motion prediction equations using site class as the site parameter[J]. Bull Seismol Soc Am,105(4):2010–2022. doi: 10.1785/0120150019
|
Zhao J X,Zhou S L,Gao P J,Long T,Zhang Y B,Thio H K,Lu M,Rhoades D A. 2015b. An earthquake classification scheme adapted for Japan determined by the goodness of fit for ground-motion prediction equations[J]. Bull Seismol Soc Am,105(5):2750–2763. doi: 10.1785/0120150013
|
Zhao J X,Zhou S L,Zhou J,Zhao C,Zhang H,Zhang Y B,Gao P J,Lan X W,Rhoades D,Fukushima Y,Somerville P G,Irikura K. 2016a. Ground-motion prediction equations for shallow crustal and upper-mantle earthquakes in Japan using site class and simple geometric attenuation functions[J]. Bull Seismol Soc Am,106(4):1552–1569. doi: 10.1785/0120150063
|
Zhao J X,Liang X,Jiang F,Xing H,Zhu M,Hou R B,Zhang Y B,Lan X W,Rhoades D A,Irikura K,Fukushima Y,Somerville P G. 2016b. Ground-motion prediction equations for subduction interface earthquakes in Japan using site class and simple geometric attenuation functions[J]. Bull Seismol Soc Am,106(4):1518–1534. doi: 10.1785/0120150034
|
Zhao J X,Jiang F,Shi P,Xing H,Huang H F,Hou R B,Zhang Y B,Yu P C,Lan X W,Rhoades D A,Somerville P G,Irikura K,Fukushima Y. 2016c. Ground-motion prediction equations for subduction slab earthquakes in Japan using site class and simple geometric attenuation functions[J]. Bull Seismol Soc Am,106(4):1535–1551. doi: 10.1785/0120150056
|
Zhu C B,Pilz M,Cotton F. 2020. Which is a better proxy,site period or depth to bedrock,in modelling linear site response in addition to the average shear-wave velocity?[J]. Bull Earthq Eng,18(3):797–820. doi: 10.1007/s10518-019-00738-6
|